This was such an amazing sequel. I personally preferred it to If I Stay. I found Adam's narrative much more interesting and we got to see the depth to his character. I loved the fact it was written from Adam's perspective I guess this could be due to the fact I felt such a connection with the whole band scene. Unlike If I Stay, in this book the characters don't seem sugar coated or without fault which I felt was really important. The book just felt a lot more real to me, if that makes sense at all.